Return to Billy's contents page
Billy King: Rites Again
Well, world history has taken another leap into a great black hole since I was talking to you last. Sad, sad, sad. Once more we seem to have as defined but unreal a divide as the Iron Curtain, except the Iron Curtain had a physical reality as well as a psychological, mental divide. And again we have the tendency to put whole peoples (now Muslims, Afghans) into categories that are defied by the vast majority of those people. Is the lesson of history that people do not learn from history? You would sadly think so. Anyway, this month my verbiage is mainly on these current realities so if you've had enough and don't want to know how I see the score, please look away now. Images
What way to make sense of six thousand dead? Well, my home town used to be just over the three thousand mark, it's a bit more now, but I think in terms of that as a unit - so it was like all the inhabitants of two towns that size being wiped out. No one deserved to die in that way. People do not deserve to die in retaliation, particularly not the increasingly desperate Afghans, driven from pillar to post, caught between rocks, mountains and hard places, who never chose the Taliban to govern them or to have Osama bin Laden as a guest.. May those who died rest in peace. May those who are about to die rest in peace - or, far, far better, may the USA and its allies see that killing people to show that killing people is wrong is immoral, illogical and counter-productive in building a world of peace and human development. God forgive them for they know what they do. There is the saying that 'Revenge is a dish best eaten cold' but revenge has no place in a civilised world. It is justice we should be talking about, and human rights - bringing those behind the 11th September attacks to justice . Gandhi was right when asked what he thought of Western civilisation and replied 'That would be a good idea.' Logic Eduardo Galeano in La Jornado of 21st September explored this better than I can. 13 years ago, he says, Afghani Muslims were the heroes of the film Rambo 3, in the time of G Bush Snr. Now they are the worst of the worst. Which makes you think that the USA has few friends, only interests. Galeano goes on to say that "Henry Kissinger was one of the first to react to the 11th September tragedy; "Those who provide support, financing, and inspiration to terrorists are as guilty as the terrorist themselves." If that's how it is, the urgent need right now is to bomb Kissinger. He is guilty of many more war crimes than bin Laden or any terrorist in the world. And in many more countries. He provided 'support, financing, and inspiration' to state terror in Indonesia, Cambodia, Iran, South Africa, Bangladesh, and all the South American countries that suffered the dirty war of Plan Condor." Galeano points out the common ground between low- and high-tech terrorism, between the terrorism of religious fanatics and market fanatics, the hopeless and the powerful. "All these worshippers of death are in agreement as well on the need to reduce social, cultural and national differences to military terms. In the name of Good against Evil, in the name of the One Truth, they resolve everything by killing first and asking questions later. And by this method they strengthen the enemy they fight." ....... The Troubles in Northern Ireland have had their share of publicity but were a teddy bears' picnic compared to some of what has gone on, and still goes on, in this small and fragile planet we call Earth. But even here, in Northern Ireland, we saw the IRA grow exponentially in strength and stature when the British government introduced curfews, internment and shoot to kill policies. It took a generation for the situation to de-escalate as far as the Good Friday Agreement. Even so there's life in the oul conflict yet and even if it is a low level conflict in a small country it shows no sign of disappearing completely (or at all?). When we consider the trauma existing here during and after our Troubles, think what exists elsewhere with usually much less financial resources to ameliorate it. It all makes me feel profoundly weary, profoundly sad, but not profoundly pessimistic; the positives in human nature have a way of showing themselves in times of danger and hardship. But please, on a global or a local scale we have to live for justice; to 'kill for justice' is to kill justice itself. Ray: the only glimmer of hope Irish neutrality, my arse US and THEM The USA considers itself post-revolutionary (the founding fathers - don't know if the founding mothers get quite the same look in) when it is really neo-post-colonial (the internal colonisation of the land and displacement of native peoples). Despite increasing Hispanic influence, particularly in the southern states of the US, and the ethnic origins of its people in dozens of European (white) and African (black) countries, the US 'culture' is English-speaking American with limited contact outside, not necessarily 'WASP' (White Anglo-Saxon Protestant) but not too far from this. And the fact that most US citizens haven't been outside their, admittedly vast, country leads to monoculturalism and lack of interest in the wider world. It is now unusual for western Europeans, for example, not to have been outside their own country. This is all reinforced by the US American culture being the dominant one in the world. This comes partly from cultural creativity - the US is home of many modern musical forms (e.g. jazz, blues, gospel, rock and roll), and of Hollywood (which is maybe more to do with money than creativity, but anyway) - the dominant film industry location. This actually makes it more difficult for people from the US to adjust to other cultures, even where they are trying hard to do so, which creates some of the situations where US citizens can be laughed at and they can misread situations (the rest of us can do that too but it unfortunately makes it easier for them to do it). US cultural hegemony is further underpinned by US economic and military power. This is why English is now the dominant world language, not so much any more to do with the people the language was named after. And with superpower might goes a tendency to have a very misplaced view of your position in the world. This isn't peculiarly US American. It happened to the Russians. It had happened to the British. This tendency seems to be to see military actions which are really pursued because of economic interests as 'policing' actions, 'keeping the world in order' etc., Behind all that might is a certain insecurity - about their military might, about their qualities as a people, about whether people like them or should like them. Why else would their government be looking at vastly expensive Star Wars programmes when they have a very divided country in terms of wealth and could use the money to help poor people get a foot on some rung of some ladder somewhere? There can be arrogance there, a lot of it sometimes in looking down on other cultures, but there can also be insecurity which they may try to hide with brashness. Image and reality may be further apart for the USA and its people than for most countries. It is hard, when writing about a country and a culture of a few million people to do justice in a few paragraphs. Hard to do it and not be arrogant and glib. Please let me know if I've got it wrong. Well, not only am I sad but I'm sad I'm on my way, won't be back for many's a day (a month to be fairly precise). Let's hope and work that sanity emerges from the chaos and that wise counsel prevails. But I won't be holding my breath. Yours in sorrow, and in some anger, Billy. |